7 Best Orders at Jersey Mike’s, According to Regulars
If I am going to pick up a sub (or hoagie as we call them in Philly) at a chain, it will always be Jersey Mike’s. I am such a fan of the New Jersey-based sub shop, which has some of the best sub rolls, freshest veggies, and high-quality cold cuts. Some subs are better than others, according to regular customers. What are the best items? Here are the 7 best orders at Jersey Mike’s, according to regulars.
Original Italian Sub
The Original Italian “Mike’s Way” with all the fixings is one of the most popular subs at Jersey Mike’s. The Italian hoagie is made with fresh-sliced meats and cheese, oil, vinegar, and herbs, and delicious sub rolls. “Absolute perfection,” a Redditor declares.
Famous Philly Cheesesteak
Many fans say Jersey Mike’s cooks up one of the best cheesesteaks among the major chains: Number 17, Mike’s Famous Philly, which features slices of steak, grilled onions, peppers & white American cheese. “And it’s not even close,” one responded. “Yep. 100%,” another agreed. One Redditor says: “As fresh as you can get at a chain.”
Club Sub
The Jersey Mike’s Club Sub (No. 8) is one of the most popular orders at Jersey Mike’s. Bread is piled high with lean, freshly shaved turkey, premium ham, provolone cheese, sizzling applewood smoked bacon, and mayonnaise. “Sooo freaking good!!!” a Facebooker says. “The best,” another agrees.
Turkey and Provolone
The #7 Turkey and Provolone is one of Jersey Mike’s most popular cold subs because it is simple but delicious. It features 99% fat-free lean turkey breast and fresh provolone cheese, typically served “Mike’s Way” with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil, oregano, and salt. “That’s my favorite sandwich right there,” says a Redditor. “My go-to. Criminally underrated,” adds another.
Roast Beef
Jersey Mike’s roast beef sub is perfection. “Jersey Mike’s roast beef is top tier,” writes a Redditor. “Definitely not dry,” agrees another. “Arguably the best thing they offer. 80% of the time I get roast beef or the club,” a Facebook user agrees. “Jersey Mike’s cooks their roast beef in house. I know because I trimmed and tied hundreds of them when I worked there,” another commented on the same post.
Mike’s Chicken Bacon Ranch
Jersey Mike’s Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak is one of the most popular specialty subs, made with applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, white American cheese, and ranch dressing with “grilled to perfection” chicken. “I just really like the chicken bacon ranch sub,” says a Redditor in a feed devoted to the sub. “So yummy it’s my favvvv , i add chipotle mayo and pickles,” another Redditor adds.
Tuna Fish Sub
You also can’t go wrong with the Tuna Fish Sub, which features the chain’s in-house, fresh tuna. “JMs tuna is massively overlooked. It’s one of their better offerings. It’s also just about the most caloric on the menu,” a Redditor says. “Their tuna is the best in the game, lots of black pepper,” another adds.