I Tried 3 Grocery Store Rotisserie Chickens and One Bird Was the Best
I love a good rotisserie chicken but don’t often buy them because I actually enjoy roasting my own—the whole process is so therapeutic and there’s no restaurant on earth that can match a proper home-cooked roast chicken. Let’s be real though—it’s not practical to roast a chicken whenever you want a quick dinner, and raw birds are even more expensive than the cooked ones these days. At times when you want a quick, healthier option, a rotisserie chicken is perfect, and so versatile. I went out to buy three rotisserie chickens from grocery stores near me to see which was the best in terms of taste, quality, and value for money—and one was a clear winner. Here’s what I found.
What to Look for in a Good Store-Bought Bird
If you’re trying to pick the best rotisserie chicken, start with appearance—the skin should look evenly roasted and golden, not pale or overly greasy. A good bird should feel firm and plump rather than soggy, and the seasoning should smell fresh without being overly salty. Checking the label can also help you spot options with cleaner ingredients and fewer additives. When these boxes are checked, you’re far more likely to walk away with a chicken that tastes like it came straight from your own oven.
Tips for Making the Most of Rotisserie Chicken
Rotisserie chicken is one of the most versatile shortcuts for quick, satisfying meals. To make the most of it, remove the meat while it’s still warm so it stays juicy, then store it separately from the bones and skin to keep everything fresh. Leftovers are perfect for salads, sandwiches, pasta dishes, or soups, and stretching the bird with a homemade stock from the bones makes it even better value. A little creativity goes a long way with this grocery store staple.
Kroger/Ralphs Simple Truth Whole Rotisserie Chicken
This Simple Truth Fresh Roasted Whole Rotisserie Chicken from Ralphs ($9.99) was underwhelming. While I appreciate there are no additives or preservatives added to this bird, there was also absolutely no flavor due to a deliberate lack of seasoning. This is great for people on low-sodium diets who want to control their intake, but it was a sad disappointment for me. The texture of the chicken was actually quite nice and tender, so this might be a good option to throw into a soup where you can control the seasoning.
Pavilions Rosemary & Garlic Chicken
I will admit the Pavilions Signature CAFE Rosemary & Garlic Whole Rotisserie Chicken ($9.99) did not look promising based on appearance alone (the poor chicken looked as if it had been thrown around a bit with the skin peeling off). However I was pleasantly surprised by the taste, with the garlic and rosemary really coming through in the rub. Sadly the meat was a little dry, and the skin was a little flabby. I would definitely try this one again to see if it’s better not under a heat lamp for hours, but it wasn’t my favorite.
Whole Foods Lemon Herb Chicken
I’ve tried Whole Foods Classic Rotisserie Chicken before, but not this Paleo Friendly Lemon Herb Rotisserie Chicken ($8.99), and of all three chickens this was the best. The meat was tender and firm without being tough, and juicy without being slimy or too moist. The bird itself was not overly fatty, and the lemon and herb seasoning was delicious without being overpowering. The seasoning could definitely do with a little more punch, but otherwise it was just about perfect. We used the leftovers to make chicken salad and it was still good two days later, and the kids especially liked this option.
