Skip to content

We Tasted 5 Bottled Coffees & This Is the Best

We tried five bottled cold brew options to find the very best-tasting one.
cold brew

April 20 is National Cold Brew Day, making it the perfect occasion to grab your favorite chilled coffee and go for a springtime stroll. But if you can't get to your favorite coffee shop or if you're just trying to save money, there are a lot of great bottled and canned cold brew options out there, too.

To find out the best at-home cold brew (other than a homemade batch, of course), I tried five cold brews in a blind taste test. My husband set them up in glasses, so I wouldn't see which was which, and I guessed almost all of them wrong! I was shocked both by the winner of the test and by the difference in taste between the canned and bottled options.

The cold brews I tried included Bean Box Rich and Creamy Cold Brew, High Brew Double Espresso Cold Brew, Starbucks Cold Brew, Trader Joe's Organic Cold Brew Coffee, and Trader Joe's Black Cold Brew Coffee. (Full disclosure: Bean Box provided its cold brew for the taste test.) I sampled them all in glasses, without milk or sugar added—but I did go back and add milk to finish off the bottle of my favorite one!

Here's which coffee I considered the best-tasting bottled cold brew, based on taste, smell, and appearance. These are the five options I tried, listed from worst to best. And for more, don't miss these 15 Classic American Desserts That Deserve a Comeback.

5

Trader Joe's Black Cold Brew Coffee

hand holding trader joes cold brew coffee can
Meghan De Maria / Eat This, Not That!

This coffee had the most unpleasant taste and smell of the five I tried. Before the blind taste test was revealed, I thought it was the bottled Trader Joe's cold brew because it looked like a dark stout with a foamy top. I also thought the burned taste might have been due to the added espresso in the bottled Trader Joe's version. However, this last-place option was actually Trader Joe's canned (and non-organic) cold brew.

Despite the nice, foamy appearance, this cold brew was very bitter and didn't smell fresh. If you're at Trader Joe's, I'd opt for the bottled cold brew, not the canned version.

RELATED: Sign up for our newsletter to get daily recipes and food news in your inbox!

4

Bean Box Rich and Creamy Cold Brew

boxes of bean box cold brew with mason jars of coffee
Courtesy of Bean Box

This Bean Box option tasted and smelled like it came from a fresh cold brew tap, which makes sense because it came from a box and not a bottle or can. It was much better than the canned Trader Joe's option, but I still found it more bitter than the top two options in this taste test. I often expect cold brew to be more bitter than iced coffee at local coffee shops, and this option was what I had in mind when I thought of cold brew. It wasn't bad if you don't mind that bitter taste, especially if you're adding a sweetener to your drink.

3

High Brew Double Espresso Cold Brew

can of high brew double espresso cold coffee

When I bought the coffees for this taste test, I didn't realize that High Brew had added sweetener and milk right in the can. It wasn't overly sweet, but I prefer to add my own cream and sugar. The sweetness helped cut any lingering bitterness, though, landing this option firmly in the middle of the taste test. If you're on the go and want an already-sweetened coffee option, this is a solid pick.

2

Trader Joe's Organic Cold Brew Coffee

hand holding bottle of organic trader joes cold brew
Meghan De Maria / Eat This, Not That!

I expected the bottled coffees to taste more bitter, especially because this one had added espresso. However, the opposite was true. The two bottled coffees shot to the top of this taste test, thanks to their smooth flavor. It was a close call between this Trader Joe's version and the top option! This cold brew had a lighter color than the other options and tasted more like an iced coffee. With a splash of Trader Joe's cream, you can have an easy, at-home version of the in-store Starbucks Sweet Cream Cold Brew.

RELATED: The easy way to make healthier comfort foods.

1

Starbucks Cold Brew

bottle of starbucks cold brew

I'm not a fan of Starbucks' at-home iced coffee bottles, so I was shocked that the chain took first place in this taste test. The Starbucks cold brew was a beautiful brown hue and was very light. There was no bitterness or lingering aftertaste; it was very easy to drink, even without milk. The pleasant scent also helped Starbucks edge out its competition from Trader Joe's. I was very happy to go back and finish off this cold brew bottle when the taste test was over.

If you don't want a bitter cup of cold brew, you can't go wrong with Starbucks' or Trader Joe's bottled options. They're smooth and delicious, whether you drink them plain or add milk and syrup.

Meghan De Maria
Meghan De Maria is a senior editor at Eat This, Not That!, specializing in food, product, and restaurant coverage. Read more
Filed Under