Skip to content

7 Costco Products That Sound Good but Aren’t Worth It

Shoppers say these Costco foods look tempting but fall short in taste and quality.

There are so many delicious foods at Costco that shoppers regularly praise. However, not every item at the warehouse comes recommended by customers. In fact, some products should be avoided altogether. From Kirkland Signature flops to brand-name busts, here are 7 Costco products that sound good but aren’t worth it.

Kirkland Signature Caesar Salad

Kirkland Signature Caesar Salad with Caesar Dressing & Croutons
Costco

Several shoppers are not fans of Kirkland Signature Caesar Salad. “WAY too much lettuce, ingredients are basic and not flavorful. No spice packet. And the dressing is just plain bad. Don’t think I’ll get another one,” one wrote on Reddit. “The Caesar salad used to be my favorite thing from Costco, but I’ve found it seems to have changed over the last year and doesn’t taste as fresh/good anymore… the quality of the lettuce can be hit/miss, the cheese doesn’t seem to be fresh and gets wet/soggy from the lettuce, and the dressing also seems to be less tasty,” another agreed.

Kirkland Signature Sliced Turkey

Kirkland Sliced Oven Roasted Turkey Breast
Costco

Shoppers highly recommend Dietz & Watson and Columbus deli meats. However, some complain that the Kirkland Signature sliced turkey 3-pack should be avoided. “It’s slimey and tastes gross. I thought it was bad but have seen other people complain about it and I think it’s just how it comes,” one shopper maintains. “The turkey is not just wet. It’s drippy and too thick. Not worth buying,” another agrees.

11 Costco Products That Shoppers Say Are Secretly Luxury

Kirkland Signature Chicken Salad

Kirkland Signature Chicken Salad
Costco

Kirkland Signature chicken salad has mixed reviews. “Maybe I’m crazy but I remember it being addictive. Nowadays it tastes like somebody walked by and knocked a salt shaker into it. No flavor except straight salt,” one shopper commented. “Yes it changed and now it seems like they just add a cup of oil to the recipe. Used to love it, no more,” agrees another. A third, who was previously a fan, maintains that the “last few times was inedible.”

Kirkland Signature Pepperoni Pizza

kirkland signature pepperoni pizza with thin crust
Costco

Costco sells a lot of top-notch frozen pizza. However, shoppers advise against throwing Kirkland Signature Pepperoni Pizza in your cart. “I will literally eat any pizza and I hated those pizzas,” one Redditor writes. “I bought it thinking it was the same pizza they serve in the cafeteria (I like it for what it is), and boy was I wrong. The frozen peperoni pizza was one of the worst things I’ve ever eaten,” another adds. “Ugh my 14 year old boy who will eat anything couldn’t choke those pizza’s down, they’re awful!” a third reveals.

The Big Bags of Bagels in the Bakery

Kirkland Signature Plain Bagels
Costco

Costco bagels are regularly ranted about. “I often will have a Bagel for breakfast with my Coffee. Now there is nothing inherently bad about Costco Bagels, they are fresh and they are cheap. But for me its that freshness that is the problem,” they wrote on Quora, revealing that they got two bags for the price of one. “Before I finished the first of these two six packs of Bagels they started to get moldy, they were very fresh and lacked the preservatives found in most store bought Bagels,” they continued. “They are nasty little things that bear no resemblance to a decent bagel,” added another shopper. “We have the same problem with them going moldy fast. Other brands stay fresh much longer,” a third said.

Kirkland Signature Frozen Chicken Bakes

Kirkland Chicken Bake
Costco

Chicken Bakes are legendary in the Costco food court. However, the Kirkland Signature freezer section version does not stack up. “Their frozen chicken bakes! They are AWFUL! I used to love going to Costco and enjoying a freshly baked chicken bake. After trying their frozen ones it gave me a bad taste and completely turned me off from their fresh ones too,” one complains. “The frozen ones can’t hold the food court ones napkins. They’re smaller and taste different,” another agrees.

7 Costco Products That Are ‘Secret Steals’ According to Members

Pad Thai

Snapdragon Chicken Pad Thai
Snapdragon Foods

The Pad Thai in the deli section at Costco may seem like an easy, ready-to-heat meal, but shoppers say you shouldn’t waste your money. “That Pad Thai that tastes like someone described pad thai over a cup and string kids telephone while drunk and craving Mexican food,” one writes. “It’s so bad, dude. Don’t even look at it.” “And it tastes so fishy- like they dumped a whole bottle of spoiled fish sauce in one tiny container! I took one bite and threw it in the trash. Completely inedible,” another agrees.

Leah Groth
Leah Groth is a writer for Eat This, Not That! and Best Life. Read more about Leah
Filed Under