Skip to content

Low-Calorie Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich Recipe

This verison might be a bit fancier, but trust us, you're not going to miss the Cheez Whiz.

The famous cheesesteak sandwich from Philly is a nutritionist's nightmare: mounds of greasy beef and fried onions; a massive, oil-soaked hoagie roll; and to top it all off, a viscous deluge of Cheez Whiz (that's right, traditional cheesesteaks are made with Cheese Whiz). But we want you to have your steak and eat it, too, so we came up with this version, which relies on a lean flank steak, a whole-wheat roll, and a yogurt-based blue cheese sauce. It's a bit fancier than the sandwich from the City of Brotherly Love, but to our tastes, it's also better. How often does better and lower fat happen in the same sentence? See our healthier version below, and enjoy this classic with a twist.

Nutrition: 400 calories, 14 g fat (4 g saturated), 730 mg sodium

Serves 4

You'll Need

2 Tbsp plain Greek yogurt (We like Fage 2%).
2 Tbsp olive-oil mayonnaise (Diffuse the caloric heft of mayo-based condiments by cutting it with 50 percent Greek yogurt.)
1⁄4 cup crumbled blue cheese
16 oz skirt or flank steak
Salt and black pepper to taste
2 cups arugula
2 tomatoes, sliced
4 whole-wheat sandwich rolls
Caramelized onions

How to Make It

  1. Combine the yogurt, mayonnaise, and blue cheese. Set aside.
  2. Heat a grill, stovetop grill pan, or cast-iron skillet until hot.
  3. Season the steak with salt and pepper and cook for 3 to 4 minutes per side (for medium-rare) until the steak is firm but still gives with gentle pressure.
  4. Allow to rest for at least 5 minutes before slicing. Slice the steak into thin strips.
  5. Divide the arugula and tomatoes among the rolls.
  6. Top with the steak and caramelized onions and drizzle each sandwich with the blue cheese mayo.

Eat This Tip

Cut into a steak to see if it's done, and you lose much of its precious juices. Instead, judge doneness by feel. Touch the center of the steak: Rare feels like a squishy dish sponge; medium is firm but yielding, like a Nerf football; and a well-done steak is hard yet springy, like a tennis ball. Regardless of feel, all meat needs to rest for 5 to 10 minutes, so the warm juices are reabsorbed by the meat, not your cutting board.

More on Cheese

  • Wrap cheese in plastic

    You Should Never Store Cheese Like This

    This simple mistake slashes cheese's lifespan.
  • cheese straws

    Make the Best Cheese Straws of All Time

    You'll obsess over this recipe.
  • best wrost cheddar cheese

    10 Best and Worst Cheddar Cheeses

    Some ingredients have no business being in your cheese.
  • best and worst single cheeses

    11 Best and Worst Cheese Singles on the Market

    Are you buying cheese, or mysterious "cheese food"?
  • Grilled cheese cut in half

    The One Ingredient Your Grilled Cheese Is Missing

    It's the condiment you never saw coming.

RELATED: The easy way to make healthier comfort foods.

2.8/5 (8 Reviews)

She Lost 100 Pounds—And Shows You How!

Registered Dietitian and Nutritionist Ilana Muhlstein lost her weight and kept it off—and in You Can Drop It!, she'll show you how to lose it, too. More than 240,000 clients have chosen her program—and now it’s yours to keep.