Skip to content

7 Subtle Signs You're Drinking Too Much Coffee

If you find yourself sipping on more cups of Joe at home lately, you're not alone. But there are effects of drinking too much.
Dark roasted coffee

You might not be able to head to your favorite local shop for the cup of coffee you once often started your morning with, but there's a good chance you've tapped into your inner barista skills and are brewing up cups of Joe at home. And with most of the world still spending a ton of time at home, you might be drinking more coffee than you ever have before, throughout the entire day instead of just the morning. But is there such a thing as drinking too much coffee?

The National Coffee Association (NCA) annual National Coffee Data Trends (NCDT) found this year that Americans under the age of 40 are almost twice as likely to drink coffee at lunchtime than someone over the age of 60, while seniors are more likely to have coffee at breakfast. Before the world was living through a global pandemic, the average American coffee drinker was consuming a little more than three cups per day. If you've found yourself drinking more than that while you're home, you might notice some changes, thanks to all the caffeine.

"An average of 400 milligrams of caffeine, or roughly the amount in four cups of coffee is generally safe for most adults. While drinking moderate amounts of coffee throughout the day is generally not harmful for your health, there are some aspects to be aware of if you are increasing your coffee intake," says Patricia Bannan, MS, RDN, nationally recognized nutritionist and healthy eating expert.

So what exactly are the signs you might be sipping on a little too much coffee? We rounded up the evidence for you.

1

You're starting to develop unwanted symptoms.

Tired young African man using laptop while sitting at the table on a sunny morning.Concept of people working hard home
Shutterstock

If you're starting to feel an onslaught of unpleasant feelings, don't think you're suddenly falling ill. There's a good chance it's all thanks to the amount of caffeine you're getting from all the coffee you're drinking.

"Higher amounts of caffeine intake can cause certain unwanted symptoms such as headaches, fast heartbeat, or irritability," says Bannan. "If you experience any of these symptoms, it may be a good idea to cut back on how much coffee you are drinking."

2

You're not sleeping well.

Sleepless woman awake and covering face in the middle of the night
Shutterstock

If you've suddenly started sipping on coffee later in the evening and then find yourself not able to enjoy a solid night's sleep, you might want to rethink your coffee consumption habits.

"Drinking coffee too close to bedtime, or using it to compensate for not getting enough sleep can impact your overall sleep pattern, and thus your health overall," Bannan says. "Caffeine can stay in your body for up to three to five hours, so drinking an afternoon cup can still affect your sleep once bedtime comes. One study found that drinking the equivalent of a double espresso can delay your circadian rhythm by 40 minutes."

Making sure you sleep enough each night is crucial as "getting enough quality sleep each night can help reduce the risk of diabetes, obesity, and high blood pressure," according to Bannan.

"If you still want to enjoy a cup of coffee later in the day, it may be helpful to switch to decaf once the afternoon hits or an herbal tea instead. Opt for a cup of white or green tea, which both have lower amounts of caffeine than coffee," she says.

3

You don't have as much energy.

Young exhausted,depressed,concentrated woman sitting in her room or office with french windows in the dark at the lamp
Shutterstock

You might be turning to coffee for as the main pick-me-up, but it could actually be draining you of your energy. See, if you keep turning to coffee for that burst of energy (thanks to the caffeine), it—as you already learned—messes with your sleep schedule, so you'll wake up feeling more tired. This then continues the cycle, and you'll end up feeling less energized throughout the day.

4

You're suffering from heartburn.

Gastroesophageal reflux disease,Woman having or symptomatic reflux acids
Shutterstock

Coffee is one of those drinks that is acidic, so it can irritate the lining of your gut and cause heartburn. If you're already someone who deals with acid reflux and you're drinking more coffee throughout the day, it could be the culprit behind the surge in heartburn.

5

You have an upset stomach.

stomach pain
Shutterstock

Along with heartburn, any stomach aches or nausea you're experiencing could be because of all the coffee you're drinking, especially if you're drinking it all on an empty stomach.

RELATED: Sign up for our newsletter to get daily recipes and food news in your inbox!

6

You're more stressed.

Man stressed while working on laptop
Shutterstock

It's understandable that you're feeling more stress right now, but the large cups of coffee you're downing all day might just be making it worse. See, thanks to—you guessed it—all that caffeine, cortisol levels (aka the body's main stress hormone) could be rising. And along with reducing your coffee consumption, we have plenty of other easy ways to lower cortisol levels so you don't feel as stressed.

7

You're dehydrated.

with closed eyes drinking clean mineral water close up, young woman holding glass
Shutterstock

If you find yourself feeling more thirsty with the more coffee you're drinking, there is a connection there! According to a French study, caffeine has a diuretic effect, which can impact hydration. You would have to be drinking a large amount of coffee to get to this point though, as another study shows that moderate caffeine consumption (that baseline of four cups) doesn't impact your risk of dehydration. If you are drinking tons of coffee to the point that you are experiencing dehydration though, be sure to swap some of those cups for some water.

Jennifer Maldonado
Jennifer Maldonado is a senior editor at Eat This, Not That!, specializing in food and health content. Read more
Filed Under