Skip to content

17 'Healthy' Foods Nutritionists Wish You'd Stop Eating

Just because a brownie is made with beans doesn't give you a good excuse to eat 20 grams of sugar.
Turkey deli-style sandwich

If you think most of the products labeled "healthy," "skinny," or "natural" are actually good for you, you couldn't be further from the truth. In fact, you might as well be eating a cookie slathered in whipped cream and drizzled with fudge because most of the labeling on packaged foods isn't regulated very strictly, which gives manufacturers free rein to use whatever buzzwords they think will drive sales. Remember: a brownie is still a brownie even if you bought it at your corner Health Nuts store.

Although the healthiest foods don't have potential pitfalls because they don't require labeling—think produce like avocados and berries—even the healthiest among us need more than apples and carrots to survive. When it comes to optimizing your health, however, there are a few things you shouldn't be loading your plate with (or at least not consider them healthy). Let's take a look at the so-called healthy foods nutritionists really wish you'd stop eating. And then to get a better idea of what you should stock up on instead, find out The 7 Healthiest Foods to Eat Right Now.

1

Whole Wheat Bread

whole wheat bread
Shutterstock

"Whole wheat bread is one of the most potentially inflammatory foods in existence since the gluten used in today's wheat bread is virtually indigestible by most people," says Miami clinical nutritionist Dr. Michael Forman. "It's amazing how much better people feel when they just stop eating it." Aside from causing inflammation, whole wheat bread also raises blood sugar and when blood sugar is raised you're more likely to store fat. Speaking of inflammation, discover the 30 Best Anti-Inflammatory Foods to eat more of!

2

Brown Sugar

Brown sugar spoon
Shutterstock

"Brown sugar is just like the white stuff; it's a refined sugar that immediately hits your bloodstream and demands insulin as a response. This promotes inflammation by irritating insulin resistance, one of the factors in almost every health problem," explains Dr. Forman.

3

Agave

Shutterstock

According to Dr. Forman agave is very close to high fructose corn syrup, which is why he recommends avoiding it if you want to lose weight and cut out health problems. There's a mistaken concept, he says, that because agave sugars go through a different pathway that it's better than your more common white sugar—but that's not the case.

And just so you know, here is the easy guide to cutting back on sugar is finally here.

4

Commercial Chicken

grilled chicken
Shutterstock

Just go on Youtube and see how these are processed; it will be enough to put you off commercial chicken for a lifetime. "They are kept in small cages, shot up with antibiotics and growth hormones, and fed unnatural foods for chickens," says Dr. Forman. Opt instead for cage-free, organic chicken.

5

Commercial Pasteurized Eggs

Eggs in pan
Shutterstock

"Ever wonder why commercial pasteurized eggs last so long in the refrigerator? They do because they have been treated with antibiotics, pasteurization, and other processes that make them last," explains Dr. Forman. "This is bad news for your body because the food is not recognized in the way nature intended and you know what happens when you 'fool' with mother nature."

6

Whole Wheat Pasta

cooked and seasoned whole wheat pasta in pan
Shutterstock

Contrary to what food manufacturers would like you to think whole wheat pasta is just as bad for you as traditional white flour pasta. Not only is the whole wheat inflammatory it creates a sugar response, according to Dr. Forman, that makes it a less than desirable food source. Not to mention that it's high in empty calories.

7

Flavored Yogurt

Flavored yogurt
Shutterstock

Most flavored yogurts have way too much sugar to be truly beneficial. "The flavoring is actually a sweet, sugar-loaded jelly that makes flavored yogurt very fattening," says Dr. Forman. The majority of flavored yogurts are also very high in calories and don't have the fiber or protein to make up for said elevated levels. Reach for a plain Greek yogurt instead—and make sure it's an Eat This!-approved choice on our list of The 20 Best & Worst Greek Yogurts, According to Nutritionists.

8

Canned Organic Beans

kidney beans
Shutterstock

"Canning is an unnatural process that takes the goodness away," says Dr. Forman. "Canning contains metals that can leak into food and cause trace amounts of metals and the real problem here is that we don't yet fully understand the effects of this. We also don't know under what conditions the products have been shipped and handled, which can make for potentially very hazardous results."

9

Pasteurized Milk

Shutterstock

The problem with pasteurized milk is that the essential enzymes required for digestion have been boiled out. "Good for the grocer, bad for you," says Dr. Forman. "If you are experiencing congestion, arthritic pain, or any inflammatory response, consider cutting milk."

10

Skim Milk

Milk
Shutterstock

"Skim dairy isn't healthy and it's not good for your weight," says Lauren Slayton, MS, RD, and founder of Foodtrainers. When you cut out all the fats in milk you're not satiated and end up consuming more than you otherwise would. Slayton also adds that when you cut out all the fat you're left with a large amount of androgens (hormones). Instead opt for low-fat, full-fat, coconut milk, almond milk, or rice milk.

11

Certain Fruits

green grapes bunch in bowl
Shutterstock

While mangoes, cherries, and grapes aren't bad per se, they can halt weight loss because they're very high in sugar. "I call them the sugary threesome," says Slayton. "Other berries and grapefruit are better options if you're prone to eating a lot of fruit." Fruit is, in fact, a fantastic way to curb a sweet tooth and unlike processed treats, cookies, and cakes there is fiber in fruit—even the sugary threesome—to mitigate blood sugar spikes. Speaking of, find out the 30 Foods With More Fiber Than an Apple!

12

Granola

granola
Shutterstock

According to Dr. Forman, most granolas are no better than cookies. "In fact, if you put some water or oil in with it and baked it, they would be cookies. Don't fool yourself into thinking one ingredient makes something healthy." Instead of granola opt for some Greek yogurt and top it with seeds, nuts, and berries. If you want more sweetness opt for dried fruit but make sure you're choosing dried fruit with no added sugar, sulfites, preservatives, or other additives. Cooked unsweetened oatmeal or sugar-free flakes are also options and topping them with crunchy fruits like apples will give you a granola-like crunch.

13

Tofu

Shutterstock

Tofu acts as an estrogen-like substance causing all kinds of havoc. In fact, soy products, in general, are loaded with problems. "Ninety percent or more are genetically modified to be 'Round Up Ready', which means that they can withstand intense chemical sprays meant to destroy plants with no effect," explains Dr. Forman. So, if the powerful chemical cannot do anything with the plant, can your body? Talk about serious food for thought…

14

Soy Milk

Shutterstock

Soy milk is worse than organic cow's milk, which is also not recommended as it can cause inflammation. "Soy milk is a highly chemicalized, processed food and should be avoided for anyone experiencing inflammation," says Dr. Forman. Remember there are plenty of non-dairy sources of calcium including leafy greens such as turnip greens, kale, and bok choy, almond, oranges, seaweed, and canned salmon. It's also important to note that almost all soy is GMO and estrogenic.

15

Fruit Juice

bottled juices
Shutterstock

Yes, and that means even fresh-pressed fruit juices. "I believe this should be a treat and enjoyed more occasionally. Fruit juices have high sugar content and zero fiber, resulting in a spike in blood sugar," says Mountain Trek's nutritionist Jennifer Keirstead. Instead of fruit juice, opt for fruit smoothies, which do have fiber. When possible, cut sugar levels by working in some vegetables. Get the recipes for The 25 Best Weight Loss Smoothies to blend up a better drink!

16

Energy Bars

Shutterstock

Don't believe the labeling; buzzwords like "healthy" and "natural" aren't regulated and most energy bars are loaded with hidden sugar, fat, calories, and artificial ingredients. If you're going to opt for an energy or food bar make sure to read labels closely and opt for ones low in sugar, high in fiber and protein, and made only with recognizable ingredients.

17

Boxed Cereals

cereal
Shutterstock

"Just like with energy bars boxed cereals can be very deceiving," says Keirstead. "Even those labeled "healthy" are often loaded with hidden sugars and processed ingredients." When shopping for cereal opt for ones high in fiber and protein and low in sugar, fat, and calories. And always avoid these 20 Worst "Healthy" Cereals!