Skip to content

A Chef Shares the Secret Ingredient Your Mac and Cheese Is Missing

If you're looking to elevate your mac and cheese dish, we have just the recipe for you.

Next to burgers, mac and cheese may just be one of the most popular American foods of all time. How satisfying is it to dip your fork or spoon into a bowl of warm, cheesy noodles? But do you know how to make the best mac and cheese recipe?

Let us start by saying there is a distinctive difference between boxed mac and cheese and mac and cheese that's made from scratch. Melting fresh cheese is matchless; powdered cheese fails to even come close to paralleling the taste of a true homemade mac.

There are several variations when it comes to macaroni and cheese, too. Some recipe developers and chefs combine several types of cheese to make a decadent, heavy bowl of creamy pasta. Others top the noodles with savory garnishes including chopped chives, caramelized onions, and crispy bacon. What if we told you there is a mac and cheese recipe that truly went against what we know to be a traditional bowl of mac and cheese?

Executive Chef Bryan Forgione at Buddy V's Ristorante (yes, as in famed baker, Buddy Valastro!) in Las Vegas provided us with a recipe for mac and cheese that he and his team make in-house at the restaurant. Find out what the secret ingredient is that makes this mac and cheese superior to all other recipes.

What's the secret ingredient to making the best mac and cheese?

Technically, there are two secret ingredients, the first one being the style of noodles. Chef Forgione uses cavatelli pasta over traditional elbow macaroni.

"You don't eat mac and cheese to have a light bite, you eat it to have a deliciously rich experience," he says, which is exactly why he swaps elbow macaroni noodles for cavatelli pasta as it both absorbs and retains the creamy cheese better.

"Small and hearty, cavatelli pasta gives the dish a sturdier taste, [with] its ridges catching and holding onto all of the cheesy flavors," he says. "Our mac and cheese carbonara takes comfort to a whole new level."

OK, then what's the other secret ingredient?

The key to making a delicious mac and cheese dish? Using egg yolk to give it an even creamier carbonara-like pasta feel. The egg yolk is the non-traditional, secret ingredient for this mac and cheese recipe.

"Buddy loves macaroni and cheese and is known for his famous carbonara in his family, so it was only natural that we combine these two beloved dishes," the chef says. "Incorporating the egg yolk adds an incredible richness, not to mention additional creaminess, that really pulls the entire dish together."

More on Cheese

  • cheese

    6 Subtle Signs You're Eating Too Much Cheese

    Back away from the brie for a bit.
  • shredded cheese

    The Hidden Ingredient In Shredded Cheese

    Stay away from that bag!
  • plate of many cheese on a cutting board

    What Happens If You Eat Too Much Cheese

    There are pros and, yes, cons, too.
  • Wrap cheese in plastic

    You Should Never Store Cheese Like This

    This simple mistake slashes cheese's lifespan.
  • cheese straws

    Make the Best Cheese Straws of All Time

    You'll obsess over this recipe.

RELATED: The easy way to make healthier comfort foods.

Cast iron vs. stainless steel: which would you recommend using for this dish?

We know both stainless steel and cast iron skillets have different strengths, which is why Forgione suggests using both if you have them.

"I recommend a stainless steel sautée pan for the initial cooking of this dish," he says. "You can transfer to a baking dish or cast iron to bake with bread crumbs for that added layer of texture and flavor."

If you're in need of new pan, consider trying Brandless Stainless Steel Saute Pan or the T-fal Pre-Seasoned Nonstick Cast Iron Skillet.

Which types of cheese do you include in your mac and cheese recipe?

This recipe calls for two kinds of cheese: either smoked mozzarella or fontina and parmesan.

"The beauty of this dish lies in its complexity of flavors, and the cheese plays an important role in creating that overall effect," says Forgione. "Both smoked mozzarella and fontina cheeses bring unique elements to the dish that really can't be replicated by other, more common cheeses."

Both fontina and smoked mozzarella elevate the flavors of any dish, which is why you should only pick one to pair with the parmesan. He says fontina is both rich and creamy and offers a subtle nutty flavor, while smoked mozzarella inherently adds a hint of smokiness to the dish.

How can I make this mac and cheese recipe at home?

Here's how you can make this next-level mac and cheese carbonara.


4 oz. Cavatelli pasta
2 tbsp pancetta
0.5 tsp coarse black pepper
6 fl. oz. heavy cream
1 oz. smoked mozzarella or fontina
2 oz. parmesan
1 tbsp Peas
1 tbsp breadcrumbs
1 egg yolk
Kosher salt, to taste


  1. Boil the pasta and reserve.
  2. Crisp pancetta in a sautée pan with the black pepper and add cream. Bring to a boil and reduce by a third.
  3. Add the pasta, peas, and cheeses, stirring to incorporate. Save 1 oz. parmesan for topping.
  4. Once all is melted, turn off the fire and add the egg. Mix and check the seasoning.
  5. Pour into dish. Top with the remaining parmesan cheese and breadcrumbs.
  6. Place in a 375-degree oven until bubbly, toasted, and delicious.
3/5 (16 Reviews)

She Lost 100 Pounds—And Shows You How!

Registered Dietitian and Nutritionist Ilana Muhlstein lost her weight and kept it off—and in You Can Drop It!, she'll show you how to lose it, too. More than 240,000 clients have chosen her program—and now it’s yours to keep.

Cheyenne Buckingham
Cheyenne Buckingham is the news editor of Eat This, Not That!, specializing in food and drink coverage, and breaking down the science behind the latest health studies and information. Read more