Magazine cover image Get the Fall Issue

17 In-N-Out Secret Menu Items You Have to Try at Least Once

You've probably heard of Animal Fries, but have you heard of any of the rest of these secret In-n-Out orders?
17 In-N-Out Secret Menu Items You Have to Try at Least OnceKaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

In-N-Out is California's home base. Famous for their super-friendly, white-hatted staff, there's not a single storefront that isn't vibrating with easygoing energy. The fast-food joint is on every tourist's to-do list, but for West Coast locals, it's more than just what meets the eye..or what's on the menu. We uncovered In-N-Out's secret menu and tried it all. Here are 17 In-N-Out secret menu items you've got to try and see for yourself.

1

Protein style burger

Protein style burger at in-n-out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

This In-N-Out secret menu all-star makes burgers accessible for all, even the carbo-concious. Wrapped in giant pieces of leafy lettuce instead of a bun, protein style burgers are still quintessentially In-N-Out (read: covered in their signature sauce).

2

4X4

4x4 burger at In-n-Out with four patties and slices of cheese Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

On the opposite end of the health spectrum, there's In-N-Out's meatiest item—the 4×4. You can order any number of patty/cheese combos (i.e. 2×2, 3×4), but In-N-Out caps it at the 4×4. Rumor has it they had to after someone super ambitious tried to order a 100×100.

3

Flying dutchman

Flying Dutchman order at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

In traditional mythology, The Flying Dutchman is a ghost ship that can never make it to port, doomed to sail the ocean forever. In urban mythology, it's simpler: Two slices of cheese between two burger patties. Apparently, In-N-Out's version got its name from Dutch founder Harry Snyder, who loved snacking on the odd-looking 2×2.

4

Scooby snack

Scooby Snack at In-n-Out with one burger patty Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

The Scooby Snack is one step simpler. This secret menu item (with hands-down the most fun name to announce at the front of the In-N-Out line) is literally just a burger patty. Zoinks!

5

Mustard grilled patty

Mustard grilled patty on a burger at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

On any burger variation, you can add a kick of flavor by asking for your patty "mustard grilled." A squirt of mustard is added to the patty and cooked on the grill. This In-N-Out secret is both sophisticated and Californian—100 percent guaranteed to impress your friends/date/friend's date.

6

Medium rare & well done

Well done burger at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Another burger modification that's untraditional for a fast-food restaurant—at In-N-Out, you can specifically ask for your burger medium-rare or well done.

7

Extra salt

Burger ordered with extra salt at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Feeling salty? A simple-yet-elegant In-N-Out secret modification is the extra salt burger patty. The chef sprinkles on an extra pinch while it's on the grill.

RELATED: The easy way to make healthier comfort foods.

8

Animal fries

Box of animal fries at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

These fries are In-N-Out's worst kept secret. Technically they haven't made their way onto the menu yet, but this mess of french fries, signature sauce, American cheese, and caramelized onions is an In-N-Out staple.

9

Animal burger

Animal burger with similar toppings as animal fries at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Big animal fry fan? Take it up a notch and order an animal burger. For this one, In-N-Out will flip your patty into the bun and then slab all the goodness of animal fries (minus the fries) on top: signature sauce, American cheese, and caramelized onions. You're welcome!

10

Roadkill fries

Roadkill fries from In-n-Out in a box Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

The only debatable item in the "animal" trifecta, roadkill fries are rumored to be sold at some In-N-Outs, but aren't universally recognized by the chain's cooks. Basically, they're animal fries with hamburger crumbled on top. At the Marina Del Rey location, the cook gave us the ingredients and we put it together ourselves.

11

Grilled cheese

Grilled cheese ordered at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Whether you like it plain or piled with tomato, lettuce, and signature sauce, word on the street is that it's the bun that really puts In-N-Out's secret grilled cheese over the top. The way it's toasted is renowned across SoCal.

12

Cheesy fries

Cheesy fries at In-n-Out with fries piled and cheese spread on top Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Technically these aren't on the menu, but, like Animal Fries, In-n-Out's been pretty bad about keeping this one on the down-low. Piled high with stacks of melted American cheese, In-N-Out's cheesy fries are a less-sloppy second to their animal cousin.

13

Cheesy fries well done

Cheesy fries well done from In-n-Out with lots of melty cheese on top Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

In-N-Out doesn't stop at burgers when it comes to modifications. You can order any type of fry well done, but the crispy fry/melted cheese combo might be the best.

14

Neapolitan shake

Neapolitan shake from In-n-Out with chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry flavors Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Put a twist in your milkshake (literally) by ordering the Neapolitan. Instead of traditional chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry, the Neapolitan swirls all three, making it In-N-Out's sweetest secret hack.

15

Arnold Palmer

Making an Arnold Palmer at In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

This legendary spin on the classic summer drink is made possible by In-N-Out's famous pink lemonade and homemade iced tea. It's self-serve, but as the cashier hands you over a cup, she'll look at you like you know what you're doing. For best results, go 60 percent pink lemonade, 40 percent iced tea.

16

Lemon up

Making a Lemon Up at In-n-Out with 7Up Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

Another self-serve secret menu item, In-N-Out's Lemon Up is a mix of their pink lemonade and 7Up. On this one, try 80 percent lemonade, 20 percent 7Up—just enough to give it a little bubble.

17

Root beer float

Root beer float with a straw from In-n-Out Kaley Roberts/Eat This, Not That!

And finally, the root beer float. The ideal way to top off an In-N-Out secret menu order, the root beer float is heavy on the ice cream, like any good rendition should be.

Get the Fall Issue

Featuring delicious weight loss recipes, quick and easy sheet pan suppers, slow cooker tips and much more!

Kaley Roberts
Kaley Roberts is a food writer. Read more
Filed Under