Skip to content

One Major Side Effect of Eating Grilled Foods, Says Science

Here's how you can reduce your exposure to harmful chemicals while cooking out this summer.
FACT CHECKED BY Faye Brennan

Fourth of July is next weekend and many Americans with big suburban backyards have likely already begun stocking up on bags of charcoal in preparation for the big cookout. But, should you be worried about ingesting grilled foods this upcoming holiday weekend?

The truth is some foods just taste better grilled, including Romaine lettuce, pineapple, plantains, and endives. Still, you've probably heard at least once before that grilling foods over a bed of charcoal could increase your risk of unfavorable health outcomes, including cancer.

RELATED: This One Food May Lower Your Colorectal Cancer Risk, New Study Says

The good news? Current research suggests this may only apply to meat—not fruits or vegetables. Charcoal by itself isn't carcinogenic, it's cooking foods with charcoal that's the issue. When grilling food, charcoal helps to create very high temperatures—that's risk number one. Risk number two is that charcoal creates a lot of smoke. Together, these can risks can produce carcinogenic effects, but specifically when cooking meat.

chef grilling meat and vegetables
David Tadevosian/Shutterstock

According to The National Cancer Institute, when muscle meat such as beef, pork, fish, or poultry is cooked using high-temperature methods including pan-frying or grilling, two chemicals form called Heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). In lab experiments, these chemicals have been shown to be mutagenic, which means they can cause changes in DNA that may increase the risk of cancer.

So the charred exterior of a grilled chicken drumstick indicates that HCAs have formed. The chemical forms as a result of high temperatures causing amino acids in meat to react with the creatine (an amino acid) in meat. Meat and seafood are the only foods that naturally contain creatine, which is why grilled fruits and vegetables are generally considered safe to consume.

RELATED: 17 Best Grilled Dessert Recipes

When the juice from meat drips onto the coals and other hot metal surfaces, it can cause flames and smoke, which causes PAHs to form. This chemical sticks to cooked meat. Keep in mind, that people are regularly exposed to PAHs via the inhalation of motor vehicle exhaust, cigarette smoke, or wood smoke, for example.

As the National Cancer Institute notes, several epidemiologic studies have lead researchers to find that high consumption of well-done, fried, or barbecued meats was associated with increased risks of colorectal, pancreatic, and prostate cancer.

Here are four ways you can reduce your risk of exposure to both chemicals.

Turn the meat often.

man grilling food outside
Shutterstock

Routinely turning meat as it sits above an open flame may help to reduce HCA formation compared with meat that isn't flipped as often while on the grill. Also, try grilling at lower temperatures if possible to avoid charring.

Remove charred portions of meat.

Shutterstock

If charring does occur, try and pick off the charred parts of meat to reduce your exposure to HCAs. Also, avoid using gravy that's made from meat drippings to reduce PAH exposure.

Grill fish instead of red meat.

grilling salmon
Shutterstock

Red meat and processed meats like hot dogs are high in fat which means they will drip onto the coals more, which increases your risk of PAH exposure. Not to mention, these meats require longer grilling times than lean meats such as chicken, turkey, and even fish. While this doesn't completely eliminate your risk of HCA exposure, it definitely reduces it.

Grill more fruits and vegetables.

Grilled veggies
Shutterstock

Fruits and vegetables don't contain creatine, therefore, you don't have to worry about HCAs or PAHs!

Now, be sure to check out 8 Costco Buys That Are Flying off the Shelves for Summer's Kickoff, Customers Say.

Cheyenne Buckingham
Cheyenne Buckingham is the news editor of Read more
Filed Under