Skip to content

We Tasted 6 Chocolate Chip Cookies, and This Is the Best One

When the craving for a sweet treat hits, these are the cookies you're going to want to add to your shopping cart.

There really is nothing quite like a chocolate chip cookie. It's the perfect sweet treat, each bite filled with crumbs of deliciousness that are crisped to perfection and enhanced flavor-wise thanks to the chocolately goodness that is sprinkled throughout. The world wouldn't be a much darker place if chocolate chip cookies didn't exist, that's for sure.

And while baking some yourself is one pastime we fully support, sometimes you just want to dig right in without having to wait for them to bake. That's where the store-bought cookies come in.

But which option is the best?

Well, we went ahead and tasted some of the most popular chocolate chip cookies you'll find in the grocery store to determine which one really is the tastiest option. In alphabetical order, here are the store-bought cookie brands we tasted.

  • Chips Ahoy!
  • Entenmann's
  • Famous Amos
  • Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse (Thin & Crispy)
  • Tate's Bake Shop

We closely examined each cookie's appearance, texture, and overall flavor to conclude which option deserves the No. 1 spot. We ranked the cookies from the not so bad to the absolute best that is most likely to have you eating the whole package in one sitting. So without further ado, see which cookie reigns supreme, and to learn more about beloved sweets, check out which 15 Classic American Desserts That Deserve a Comeback.

6

Famous Amos Chocolate Chip

famous amos chocolate chip chocolate chip cookies bag
Ann Marie Langrehr/Eat This, Not That!

If you really like your cookies to have major crunch, Famous Amos is the option for you. Our tasters agreed these bite-sized cookies were the crunchiest—and therefore left behind a lot of crumbs. Overall, these cookies had more of a bland, biscuit flavor to them, though, which isn't really what you're looking for when you're in the mood for a decadent cookie.

"I would only eat these if they were the only option. Yuck!" one taster said.

That says all you need to know…

5

Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Thin & Crispy, Milk Chocolate Chip

pepperidge farm milk chocolate chip chocolate chip cookies bag
Ann Marie Langrehr/Eat This, Not That!

Out of all the cookies that were tasted, Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Thin & Crispy Milk Chocolate Chip flavor received the highest ranks for their appearance, as they "look the most like soft, fresh-baked cookies." But these really are thin and crispy, as the name suggests. One taster noted the cookies were a bit too sweet for her liking and the milk chocolate was a bit, well, milky in flavor.

4

Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Thin & Crispy, White Chocolate Chip

pepperidge farm white chocolate chip chocolate chip cookies bag
Ann Marie Langrehr/Eat This, Not That!

Oh, look, another Farm Farmhouse Thin & Crispy option! The white chocolate chip variety scored higher than its milk chocolate chip cousin, and that's because of the cookies' "super buttery flavor," as the tasters noted. The white chocolate makes for a richer tasting treat and if you're looking to divert from the traditional milk chocolate, this isn't a bad substitute.

3

Chips Ahoy! Chocolate Chip Cookies

chips ahoy chocolate chip cookies bag
Ann Marie Langrehr/Eat This, Not That!

We're just going to say it—Chips Ahoy! is a classic that brought on a wave of nostalgia for our tasters.

"They are hard rock honestly, but I don't mind because one bite, and it reminds me of being a kid in the lunchroom again," one taster said. While these cookies looked the most artificial and processed, our tasters were pleased with the flavor.

"I like the subtle sweet [taste] and the mini chips melt in your mouth," another taster added.

Looking for more? Sign up for our newsletter to get daily recipes and food news in your inbox!

2

Entenmann's Chocolate Chip Cookies Original Recipe

entenmanns chocolate chip cookies bag
Ann Marie Langrehr/Eat This, Not That!

If you're looking for a soft cookie that best mimics that of a freshly baked batch in appearance, these mini Entenmann's cookies are the way to go. Our tasters agreed these cookies were more sugary than some of the other options, but they were still enjoyable.

1

Tate's Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies

tates chocolate chip cookies bag
Ann Marie Langrehr/Eat This, Not That!

And now for the top dog, or shall we say cookie, in the grocery store. It's none other than Tate's Bake Shop.

Our tasters really couldn't stop raving about these cookies!

"These are nice and thin, as I'm not a thick cookie fan. They're slightly buttery with a great amount of crunch, like my favorite type of homemade cookies are," one taster said.

Another tasted called these cookies her "go-to" and said she can "eat a whole bag of these in one sitting, as the crunch is addicting."

When in doubt, go for the Tate's!

Jennifer Maldonado
Jennifer Maldonado is a senior editor at Eat This, Not That!, specializing in food and health content. Read more
Filed Under