Skip to content

The Best & Worst Greek Yogurts in 2021—Ranked!

"Nonfat" doesn't necessarily mean healthy.

Greek yogurt is a healthy, delicious snack and often a useful ingredient in cooking. And it exists in so many flavors—from the sweet to the sour to the fruity and beyond—that there's almost surely a type you'll enjoy.

On the other hand, when we look at various brands of Greek yogurt through the lens of nutrition, things get less subjective and more easily categorized in terms of best and worst. That's because while many Greek yogurts are indeed nutritious and delicious, packing in the protein and low in or devoid of fats, others are rather lacking in nutritional value.

So choose your Greek yogurt with care, because the right one can be a nutritional powerhouse. "Greek yogurt is a great source of nutrients for our bodies, like calcium and protein," says Kristen Carli, RD, a Registered Dietitian Nutritionist and the owner of Camelback Nutrition & Wellness in Phoenix, Ariz. "Regular plain Greek yogurt contains less sugar and double the amount of protein compared to low-fat yogurts."

We have ranked most of the top brands of Greek yogurt based on the calories, fats, sugars, and sodium you'll find in a serving, and as you'll see, the numbers can vary widely. You'll also notice that nonfat is not always a guarantee of a healthy option.

And for the record, while there are many great brands creating vegetarian- and vegan-friendly takes on Greek yogurt, for our purposes we're sticking with dairy-based varieties. We are also sticking with unflavored—aka plain—Greek yogurt, as comparing, say, a plain nonfat Greek yogurt from one brand to a Honey Vanilla flavor from another is an apples-to-oranges situation.

This ranking starts with the least healthy options in the category and ends with the absolute best Greek yogurt you can eat.

And for more, check out the 100 Unhealthiest Foods on the Planet.

15

The Greek Gods Traditional

greek gods plain traditional

Per serving: 220 Calories, 14 grams Fat, 9 grams Saturated Fat, 15 grams Sugar, 150 milligrams Sodium, 9 grams Protein

Noting that the serving sizes of Greek Yogurt are almost always 227 grams (or a full cup) or 170 grams (3/4 of a cup) and that this one is in the former larger serving category, it's just a not great choice if you're trying to be great about your health, given the fats, sugars, and sodium. It's also lacking in the protein department.

RELATED: Don't forget to sign up for our newsletter to get the latest restaurant news delivered straight to your inbox.

14

Cabot Whole Milk

cabot greek yogurt

Per serving: 230 Calories, 16 grams Fat, 10 grams Saturated Fat, 4 grams Sugar, 80 milligrams Sodium, 14 grams Protein

This is very much a whole milk Greek yogurt, thus it's pretty heavily laden with calories (especially for a 170-gram serving) and fats, but it's also a pretty solid source of protein and it's low in sugar and sodium, so there's some balance there.

13

Fage Total 5% Milkfat

fage total greek yogurt

Per serving: 210 Calories, 11 grams Fat, 8 grams Saturated Fat, 7 grams Sugar, 80 milligrams Sodium, 20 grams Protein

Sure, this Greek yogurt is pretty heavy on calories and fat, and it's got a fair amount of sugar compared to other options. But with 20 grams of protein per 227-gram serving, it delivers big on this necessary nutrient.

12

Stonyfield Organic 100% Grassfed

stonyfield greek yogurt

Per serving: 190 Calories, 8 grams Fat, 5 grams Saturated Fat, 7 grams Sugar, 80 milligrams Sodium, 22 grams Protein

This organic Greek yogurt from Stonyfield matches many others in its stats for fats (both overall and saturated), sugar content, and sodium, but it manages to be a bit lower in calories and higher in protein than a few of the nearest comps.

11

The Greek Gods Nonfat

greek gods nonfat greek yogurt

Per serving: 130 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 18 grams Sugar, 180 milligrams Sodium, 12 grams Protein

What is a nonfat Greek yogurt doing at this point in our rundown, when there are still many yogurts with fat in them to go? Just take a look at the stats this one has when it comes to sugar and sodium and you'll have your answer.

10

Maple Hill Creamery Whole Milk

maple hill organic creamery

Per serving: 150 Calories, 7 grams Fat, 3.5 grams Saturated Fat, 8 grams Sugar, 65 milligrams Sodium, 22 grams Protein

This moderately fatty, low sodium, and high protein Greek yogurt moves us into the middle ground in terms of health, balancing a good protein-to-calorie ratio but still having a bit more fat and sugar than one hopes to see.

9

365 Organic Whole Milk

organic greek yogurt 365

Per serving: 150 Calories, 6 grams Fat, 3.5 grams Saturated Fat, 5 grams Sugar, 65 milligrams Sodium, 16 grams Protein

You'll find a great overall balance in this option. The fats are relatively low, the sugar and sodium quite modest for the product category, and the protein decent if not stunning.

8

Chobani Low-Fat

chobani low fat plain

Per serving: 130 Calories, 3.5 grams Fat, 2 grams Saturated Fat, 4 grams Sugar, 60 milligrams Sodium, 17 grams Protein

The last Greek yogurt on this list that has any fats, this one does not have much fat, nor does it have much sugar or sodium per serving. And while the calorie count is modest too, it does have more protein than most Greek yogurts on our list.

7

365 Organic 0% Milkfat

365 organic greek yogurt

Per serving: 100 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 5 grams Sugar, 65 milligrams Sodium, 16 grams Protein

From here on out, the numbers tend to get pretty close. This one is, by all means, a healthy choice for nonfat Greek yogurt, but it does have a bit more sodium and sugar and a few more calories than the others on a serving comparison basis.

6

Happy Belly Nonfat

happy belly greek yogurt

Per serving: 100 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 6 grams Sugar, 60 milligrams Sodium, 17 grams Protein

Happy Belly is an Amazon brand, but don't let that make you think it's cheap or shoddy: this Greek yogurt is almost a direct comp to the organic Whole Foods brand (which is also owned by Amazon), except that it has less sodium, more protein, and only a bit more sugar.

5

Great Value Nonfat

great value nonfat yogurt

Per serving: 90 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 7 grams Sugar, 70 milligrams Sodium, 17 grams Protein

This Greek yogurt has 10 fewer calories than its predecessor on the list yet the same amount of protein and only a bit more sugar and sodium—negligibly small amounts, really. Another thing that's small about this one is the price tag you'll find on it at Walmart.

4

Oikos Nonfat

 

dannon oikos greek nonfat yogurt

Per serving: 80 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 6 grams Sugar, 60 milligrams Sodium, 15 grams Protein

While not a heavy hitter when it comes to protein, this Greek yogurt from Oikos holds its own there. And just look at the numbers when it comes to sodium and calories. As for sugars, no cause for concern there at six grams, which translates to about 2% of your daily recommended amount.

3

Good & Gather Nonfat

good gather plain greek nonfat yogurt

Per serving: 100 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 6 grams Sugar, 55 milligrams Sodium, 18 grams Protein

This Target brand nonfat Greek yogurt has the lowest sodium content of any on the list, but is near the top when it comes to the protein content. And it's in that 100-calorie-per-serving sweet spot, too, not to mention the moderate sugars and zero fats.

2

Wallaby Organic Nonfat

wallaby organic nonfat

Per serving: 100 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 5 grams Sugar, 65 milligrams Sodium, 16 grams Protein

Looking for a perfect Greek yogurt to use for anything from a snack to an ingredient in a recipe? Then this fat-free, low sugar, low sodium option is a fine choice, largely because it's less tart than many Greek yogurts and will readily meld into the other ingredients you're using.

1

Chobani Non-Fat

chobani non-fat plain

Per serving; 90 Calories, 0 grams Fat, 0 grams Saturated Fat, 4 grams Sugar, 65 milligrams Sodium, 16 grams Protein

The healthiest Greek yogurt on our list is this nonfat option from Chobani, which has just 90 calories per serving, a scant four grams of sugar per serving, and a decent dose of protein given how low all of its other stats are. It also has a stellar 4.8-star rating on Amazon at present with nearly 5,000 reviews posted and counting.

For more, check out the 108 Most Popular Sodas Ranked By How Toxic They Are.

Steven John
Steven John is a freelancer writer for Eat This, Not That! based just outside New York City. Read more