Skip to content

15 Discontinued Fast-Food Desserts That Deserve a Comeback

RIP, McDonald's Cinnamon Melts.
McDonalds sign

Fast-food chains like McDonald's and Burger King are always improving their menus, adding new must-have items to the list of offerings. But all of those fun new treats mean that some of your favorites will inevitably go away at some point. And while we love the new items, too, we can't help but miss these discontinued fast-food desserts.

From the various apple pies we've lost over time to McFlurry and Frosty flavors that didn't make it, you'll love reminiscing about these fast-food items of yore. And for even more nostalgia, don't miss these 19 Beloved Fast Foods You'll Never Be Able to Order Again.

1

Burger King Dutch Apple Pie

burger king dutch apple pie
Courtesy of Burger King

Last month, Burger King revealed that it's discontinuing its Dutch apple pie. The dessert wasn't a favorite in our fast-food dessert taste test, but a comeback could be BK's chance to make this dessert better! Every fast-food chain deserves an apple pie (and yes, we're looking at Taco Bell's discontinued caramel apple empanada, too).

RELATED: Sign up for our newsletter to get daily recipes and food news in your inbox!

2

McDonald's Old Apple Pie Recipe

McDonald's apple pie

Speaking of fast-food apple pies, fans may remember that in 2018, McDonald's changed its apple pie recipe to be healthier. We're all for making smarter food choices, but let's be honest: The old apple pie tasted way better.

And whatever you do, steer clear of these 10 Worst Menu Items at McDonald's.

3

Taco Bell Caramel Apple Empanada

taco bell storefront
Rob Wilson/Shutterstock

We couldn't mention the other apple treats without featuring this beloved Taco Bell item, too. That creamy apple filling and that perfectly crispy empanada shell? Our hearts will not go on.

RELATED: Your ultimate restaurant and supermarket survival guide is here!

4

Shake Shack Custard of the Week

custard cups from shake shack
Shake Shack/Facebook

Long before Shake Shack was an international megachain, it served a weekly custard flavor at its local stores. There were inventive shake bases like strawberry cheesecake or peanut butter. These days, the menu at Shake Shack stays the same, with only seasonal selections on rotation. (Right now, for example, Shake Shack is offering the s'mores shake.) The creamy treats are still superb, but there was something fun about checking the calendar for upcoming flavors.

5

Shake Shack Concretes

shake shack frozen custard
Courtesy of Shake Shack

Speaking of Shake Shack, another casualty of the pandemic has been the chain's blended concretes. Different locations had different mix-ins for the treats. But during the pandemic, your only options are vanilla and chocolate frozen custard, sans toppings.

RELATED: This 7-day smoothie diet will help you shed those last few pounds.

6

Burger King Cini-Minis

Burger king cini minis
lugnutsoldcrap/YouTube

These mini cinnamon roll bites were the best part of visiting BK. Sadly, they're no longer on the menu, despite an adamant Change.org petition.

7

McDonald's Cinnamon Melts

cinnamon rolls
Shutterstock

While Burger King had the Cini-Minis, McDonald's had Cinnamon Melts. The rip-apart treat was like getting the gooey center of a cinnamon roll in every bite.

And to keep the reminiscing going, don't miss these 15 Fast-Food Menu Items You Might Never See Again.

8

Coffee Toffee Twisted Frosty

wendys chocolate frosty
Courtesy of Wendy's

This treat came with a 2000s-style music video. No, really. And the flavor doesn't sound half bad!

9

Burger King Bacon Sundae

ice cream pie topped with bacon slice
Shutterstock

Putting bacon on everything is a time-honored American tradition. But Burger King took things too far when the chain added bacon to soft-serve in 2012.

RELATED: Learn how to harness the power of tea to lose weight.

10

Taco Bell Chocoladilla

taco bell cantina
Rob Wilson/Shutterstock

This candy-filled treat was only available in Wisconsin in 2017. But considering the fact that Taco Bell already broke our hearts with the apple empanada, bringing back this chocolate quesadilla is the least the chain could do.

11

Taco Bell Cinnamon Crispas

tortilla chips with cinnamon sugar
Macy Alexzandra Villars/Shutterstock

Cinnamon Twists are still on the Taco Bell menu. But anyone who's tried them knows they're fairly tasteless. What we wish we could have back is the Cinnamon Crispas, which were cinnamon-sugar tortilla chips. Yum.

12

Taco Bell Airheads White Mystery Freeze

taco bell sign for starburst freeze
Shutterstock

Taco Bell just keeps breaking our hearts! This drink combined the beloved Taco Bell Freeze with the classic candy flavor that kept fans guessing. At one point, there was a Starburst freeze, too.

13

KFC Apple Turnover

two apple turnovers on paper
Shutterstock

We have one more apple-flavored treat to add to the fast-food dessert graveyard. The KFC apple turnover was a fan favorite. But the only desserts on KFC's menu now are chocolate chip cookies and for some reason, Bundt cakes.

14

McDonald's Shrek McFlurry

mint chocolate milkshake with red straw
Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock

If you were in Canada, the early 2000s brought you the Mint Ogre-Load McFlurry. In the U.S., there was the Swamp Sludge McFlurry. Whatever it was called, this Shrek-themed treat was a gimmick that worked.

15

Costco Chocolate Soft-Serve

costco menu signs with acai bowl and frozen yogurt
Shutterstock

When Costco added the acai bowl to the menu at its U.S. stores, the chocolate soft-serve was removed. If we could only have one item, we'd rather it be the chocolate one.

And the next time you're grocery shopping, don't miss these 30 Cheap Costco Buys That Make the Membership Worth It.

Meghan De Maria
Meghan De Maria is a senior editor at Eat This, Not That!, specializing in food, product, and restaurant coverage. Read more