Skip to content

The Best Pie Slice in Every State

From key lime to classic apple, there's a pie for every dessert lover on this list.

Is there anything more American than a slice of pie? Whether you like a classic apple pie or a rich chocolate variety, there's a pie flavor out there for everyone. And there are plenty of places to pick up the treat, too, including diners and even places like McDonald's.

But if you're looking for the absolute best pie slice, where can you go? We're taking the guesswork out of that question. We've partnered with Yelp to find the best slice of pie in every state, based on which restaurants had many reviews that mentioned pie, along with user rankings. Keep reading to see what pie won out in your state!

ALABAMA: Pecan Pie at Uncle Mick's Cajun Market & Cafe in Prattville

slice of pecan pie on styrofoam plate
Chris S./Yelp

Pecan pie is a Southern delight, and diners love the version at this Alabama restaurant. You can't go wrong with the seafood gumbo and dirty rice, either.

ALASKA: Strawberry Rhubarb Pie at A Pie Stop in Anchorage

strawberry rhubarb pie slice on paper plate with crumb topping
Jessie L./Yelp

Yelp reviewers seemed to enjoy all of the pies here, but the strawberry rhubarb looks especially delicious. Other popular options include Key Lime and triple berry. Bonus: This restaurant offers gluten-free crusts, too!

ARIZONA: Peach Pie at Oracle Patio Cafe in Oracle

slice of peach pie on plate
Beth B./Yelp

Peach and strawberry rhubarb are two popular pie flavors at this casual spot. Stay for lunch while you're here, too.

ARKANSAS: Apple Pie at Fork and Crust Pie Company in Rogers

slice of apple pie
Jason B./Yelp

With options like buttermilk, peach blueberry, and German chocolate pies, you're bound to find something you like here. But you can't beat classic apple pie.

CALIFORNIA: Sweet Potato Mini Pie Morika's Southern Delights Dessert Company in Laguna Hills

three mini sweet potato pies
Morika's Southern Delights Dessert Company/Yelp

Aren't these mini pies adorable? Enjoy a little taste of the South right in California with this sweet potato pie.

COLORADO: Raspberry Pie at Piece, Love and Chocolate in Boulder

slice of raspberry pie on red plate
Lyubov L./Yelp

This sweet dessert spot has more than just pie, so it's perfect for groups with various tastes. The raspberry pie is absolutely picture-perfect.

CONNECTICUT: Pumpkin Custard Tart at Bantam Bread in Bantam

pumpkin custard tart from bantam bread in connecticut
Jim T./Yelp

These tarts are known as hand pies by some Yelp reviewers, and they're too pretty not to include on the list. Not a pumpkin fan? Try flavors like peach blueberry and sour cherry.

DELAWARE: Key Lime Pie at Off the Hook in Bethany Beach

slice of key lime pie with lime slice
Jen A./Yelp

Yelp reviewers called this key lime pie delicious, making it the perfect way to cap off a seafood meal. You can't go wrong with the main courses, either.

FLORIDA: Country Chocolate Pie at Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe in Atlantic Beach

country chocolate and apple pie slices
Maisha R./Yelp

"The Country Chocolate was decadent, rich, and delightfully sweet without overdoing the chocolate or the sweetness," Yelp reviewer Matt M. wrote of this pie. Enough said.

GEORGIA: Peanut Butter Pie at Jonah's Fish & Grits in Thomasville

slice of peanut butter pie with fudge and whipped cream
Eric R./Yelp

Yelp reviewers encourage seafood fans to save room for this delectable dessert. Topped with fudge and whipped cream, it's impossible to resist.

HAWAII: Chocolate Haupia Pie at Maui Pie in Kihei

chocolate haupia pie slice
Chad M./Yelp

Get an authentic taste of Hawaiian food with this chocolate and coconut pie. If the flavor doesn't appeal to you, Maui Pie has an extensive menu of fruit and cream pies, as well as savory options like a chicken pot pie.

IDAHO: Bourbon Pecan Pie at Boise Pie Co. in Boise

bourbon pecan pie slice
Drew C./Yelp

This restaurant's menu features both savory pies and desserts, so you can eat an entire pie-based meal here. Try the key lime pie, too.

ILLINOIS: Chocolate Chess Pie at The Happy Apple Pie Shop in Oak Park

chocolate chess pie slice on white plate
Sarah S./Yelp

Sure, you can't go wrong with the signature apple pie at this beloved pie shop. But the fudgy chocolate chess pie is a must-try, too.

INDIANA: Rhubarb Pie at Clay's Family Restaurant in Fremont

slice of rhubarb pie on plate
Pam P./Yelp

Many reviews of this restaurant mention the pie, and you can't go wrong with the fruit-based options. Take a slice with you on the road!

IOWA: Key Lime Pie at Flying Mango in Des Moines

slice of key lime pie with fresh lime slices
Darren K. Fisher/Shutterstock

This barbecue restaurant is as beloved for its desserts as it is for its meats. Give the key lime or blueberry pie options a try!

KANSAS: Pineapple Coconut Pie at Bradley's Corner Cafe in Topeka

pineapple coconut pie slice on plate
Sam A./Yelp

The pie menu at this cafe rotates, but there are always plenty of options. This pineapple coconut flavor looks especially unique.

KENTUCKY: Dutch Caramel Apple Pie at Homemade Ice Cream & Pie Kitchen in Louisville

dutch caramel apple pie
Erin B./Yelp

"You will not regret anything you buy from Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen," one Yelp review reads. Well, when you put it that way, we might just have to try every pie on the menu.

LOUISIANA: Wookiee Pie at Fry and Pie in New Orleans

individual wookie pie serving
Wendy G./Yelp

Ever heard of a Wookiee pie? (And no, they're not just for Star Wars fans.) This peanut butter and chocolate pie is perfect for peanut butter cup lovers.

MAINE: Blueberry Pie at Islandbound Treats in Southwest Harbor

blueberry pie in baking pan with slices removed
Shuai M./Yelp

Take one look at this blueberry pie, and you'll understand why customers can't get enough of it. The juicy, plump berries make for a delicious pie filling, perfectly complementing the flaky crust.

MARYLAND: Ube Pie at Gwenie's Pastries in Rockville

slice of ube pie with purple whipped cream
Tawfeeq K./Yelp

Ube is still a trendy food, and now you can enjoy the purple yam in pie slices. This one is just as delicious as it is Instagrammable.

MASSACHUSETTS: Ricotta Pie at Modern Pastry in Boston

ricotta pie from modern pastry in massachusetts
Jay G./Yelp

Yelp reviewers can't stop raving about the ricotta pie at this Boston shop. There are cannolis and cakes, too, making this the perfect dessert stop.

MICHIGAN: Chocolate Pecan Pie at Crane's in the City in Holland

chocolate pecan pie slice on white plate
Alan W./Yelp

This cozy shop serves fresh donuts and a variety of pies. Grab a warm sandwich and a slice or two, and sit back and relax.

MINNESOTA: Apple Pie at Cornerstone Cafe & Catering in Monticello

apple pie slice with whipped cream
Joline E./Yelp

This cozy cafe is a great spot for a meal, but don't skip out on the dessert. Yelp reviewer Joline E. called this "the best apple pie I've ever had," so you'll want to save room.

MISSISSIPPI: Coconut Cream Pie at Cotton Blues in Hattiesburg

slice of coconut cream pie
Sandy A./Yelp

This Southern restaurant offers comfort classics like coconut cream pie, lemon icebox pie, and strawberry icebox pie. "The coconut cream pie was one of the best I've ever had," wrote Yelp reviewer Judy D.

More on Dessert

  • Frozen pies pecan pumpkin apple

    15 Healthy Pie Recipes for Pie-Lovers

    Indulge in a delicious slice minus the guilt.
  • snack aisle

    The 30 Worst Cookies You Can Buy

    We don't mean to break your heart, but...
  • molten lava cake

    What Happens to Your Body When You Eat Dessert Every Day

    Indulging your sweet cravings every day can have disastrous effects on your health.
  • spring fruit and cream tart slices with strawberries, pineapple, kiwi, and blueberries

    50 Amazing Summer Dessert Recipes

    Bonus: They're actually healthy, too.
  • finished milkshakes with straws

    How to Make the Best Old-Fashioned Milkshake

    These will rival the ones at the ice cream shop.

MISSOURI: Huckleberry Pie at Brady's Public House in Kansas City

mini huckleberry pie with whipped cream
Liz B./Yelp

Whatever the Pie of the Day is when you go to Brady's, it's sure to be good. Pie flavors have included banana toffee cream pie, butterscotch sweet potato pie, and pineapple custard. For the main course, there are savory pies like steak pies and pot pies, too.

MONTANA: Huckleberry Pie at The Huckleberry Patch in Hungry Horse

slice of huckleberry pie
Jadyn N./Yelp

Based on the name alone, you can tell that the huckleberry pie at this dessert spot has to be good. "It's been over a month, but I still think back [on] that slice of huckleberry pie from The Huckleberry Patch," wrote Yelp reviewer Ana P. Now that's a glowing recommendation!

NEBRASKA: Blood Orange Coconut Pie at Modern Love in Omaha

slice of blood orange coconut pie
Kimmi L./Yelp

The food at this vegan restaurant is so delicious, it will appeal to plant-based folks and carnivores alike. The dessert menu includes a rotating selection of pies as well as soft serve, in case you want your slice a la mode.

NEVADA: Sweet Potato Pie at Suzuya Patisserie in Las Vegas

slice of sweet potato pie
Lily B./Yelp

Whatever dessert you're looking for, you'll find it at Suzuya. The picture-perfect treats include everything from sweet potato pie to green tea cake to panna cotta.

NEW HAMPSHIRE: Peanut Butter Pie at The Arbor Restaurant and Function
Facility

slice of peanut butter pie
Megan Betteridge/Shutterstock

"The peanut butter pie is to die for," Yelp reviewer Janna B. wrote. For a more savory option, fans also raved about the Shepherd's pie.

NEW JERSEY: Pumpkin Pecan Pie at Erie Coffee & Bakery in Rutherford

whole pumpkin pecan pie with whipped cream and pumpkin seeds
Sabrina S./Yelp

This pie is as delicious as it looks. Other delicious options include the apple cranberry pie and the caramel apple pie.

NEW MEXICO: Banana Cream Pie at Coyote Cafe in Santa Fe

mini banana creme pie
Coyote Cafe/Yelp

"Banana Cream Pie! I thought I'd died and gone to heaven," wrote Yelp reviewer Debra H. We hope this dessert won't literally send you to an early grave, but it really is that good.

NEW YORK: Pecan Pie at Two Little Red Hens in New York City

pecan pie slice
Juan M./Yelp

"Best pecan pie ever!" wrote Juan M. in a Yelp review. This bakery is also known for cupcakes and cheesecake—anything you get there will be delicious.

NORTH CAROLINA: Cherry Chocolate Chip Pie at Baked Pie Company—Woodfin in Asheville

pie flight with three pie slices and ice cream
Tatiana L./Yelp

Try a pie flight so you can try even more delicious options at this Southern bakery. With flavors from buckeye pie to gluten-free chocolate chip pie, there's something for everyone.

NORTH DAKOTA: Key Lime Pie at Nichole's Fine Pastry & Café in Fargo

key lime pie slice
Brad B./Yelp

"The key lime pie and the creme brûlée are amazing," wrote Yelp reviewer Alice A. Another review called this bakery "absolutely magical," so you should definitely stop by if you're visiting Fargo.

RELATED: Your ultimate restaurant and supermarket survival guide is here!

OHIO: Orange Sage Pumpkin Pie at Rood Food and Pie in Lakewood

pumpkin pie slice with top crust
Elise M./Yelp

You can't go wrong with any of the pie options here, and diners are loving the main dishes, too. Try the seasonal pumpkin pie for a real treat.

OKLAHOMA: Drunken Turtle Pie at Pie Junkie in Oklahoma City

drunken turtle pie
Pie Junkie/Yelp

With chocolate, pecans, bourbon caramel, and a graham cracker crust, this pie is a top seller for a reason. Try a slice, or bring home a whole pie—you won't regret it.

OREGON: Brumble Berry Pie at The Pie Guy in North Plains

whole brumble berry pie in box
Tricia O./Yelp

This store specializes in one thing: homemade pies. The brumble berry is delicious, but the other fruit flavors are, too.

PENNSYLVANIA: Sweet Potato Pie at The Sweet Life Bakeshop in Philadelphia

whole sweet potato pie in pan
Shannan D./Yelp

"Definitely the best bakery in the area," wrote Yelp reviewer Tavonia Nicole S. "The banana pudding and sweet potato pie are both phenomenal." Stop by this bakery for a little slice of Southern heaven, right in Philadelphia.

RHODE ISLAND: Dutch Apple Pie at Pastiche in Providence

dutch apple pie slice
Alma C./Yelp

"I can't recommend the dutch apple pie enough," wrote Yelp reviewer David M. Sometimes, classic is best.

SOUTH CAROLINA: Buttermilk Pie at Red Shed Diner & Produce in Graniteville

slice of buttermilk pie in tin pan
B J./Yelp

Are you even a true Southerner if you haven't had buttermilk pie? This custardy treat is a Southern standard, and this diner serves up one of the best.

SOUTH DAKOTA: Coconut Custer Pie at Black Hills Burger and Bun Co in Custer

coconut custer pie slice
Jacob L./Yelp

This cleverly named coconut pie has plenty of local fans. If you're in the area, give it a try for yourself.

TENNESSEE: Chocolate Pie with Meringue at Arnold's Country Kitchen

chocolate pie slice with meringue
Julie M./Yelp

"Try the chocolate pie! It was quick, fast and fantastic," Lacey B. wrote on Yelp. There are plenty of rave reviews for the restaurant's main course foods, too.

TEXAS: Cherry Pie at Papi's Pies in Round Rock

cherry pie slice with fork
Karen D./Yelp

There are plenty of five-star Yelp reviews for a variety of items at Papi's Pies. The cozy spot also offers brunch items like sandwiches and quiches.

UTAH: Peach Blackberry Pie at Burr Trail Grill in Boulder

peach and blackberry pie slice
Fabienne T./Yelp

Take a break from hiking the Utah scenery at this homey grill. And be sure to finish off your meal with a tasty slice of pie.

VERMONT: Sour Cream Strawberry Rhubarb Pie at The Southern Pie Cafe in Chester

slice of sour cream strawberry rhubarb pie with ice cream
Ashley T./Yelp

Who doesn't want a taste of the South all the way up in Vermont? Try the sour cream strawberry rhubarb or sour cream apple pies for new twists on old favorites.

VIRGINIA: Raspberry Chocolate Pie at Proper Pie Co. in Richmond

raspberry chocolate pie slice
CB R./Yelp

"This pie shop has the best sweet or savory pies around," wrote Yelp user Liz R. Another reviewer called these pies "life-changing," so you can't go wrong.

WASHINGTON: Custard Pie at Cakes of Paradise in Seattle

custard pie with raspberries
Miss Ninja/Yelp

Sure, this store is known for its cakes, but the pies deserve recognition, too. In addition to the custard pie, Yelp reviewers seem to love the macadamia nut pie and the coconut cream pie.

WEST VIRGINIA: Key Lime Pie at Blakeley Street Bakery in Charles Town

whole key lime pie topped with whipped cream
Blakeley Street Bakery/Yelp

This sweet shop offers a variety of treats, including fruit-flavored mini pies in addition to the whole ones. Stop in to satisfy your sweet tooth!

WISCONSIN: Chocolate Cream Pie at Stockholm Pie & General Store in Stockholm

chocolate cream pie slice
Nina B./Yelp

"This is the best pie I've had in the Midwest!" wrote Yelp user Kate R. Bring a group of friends to try multiple pie flavors at this down-home store.

WYOMING: Blueberry Pie at The Pie Lady Restaurant in Cheyenne

slice of blueberry pie
Stacey K./Yelp

Could anything at a restaurant called The Pie Lady be bad? This blueberry pie looks like it's bursting with flavor.

She Lost 100 Pounds—And Shows You How!

Registered Dietitian and Nutritionist Ilana Muhlstein lost her weight and kept it off—and in You Can Drop It!, she'll show you how to lose it, too. More than 240,000 clients have chosen her program—and now it’s yours to keep.

Meghan De Maria
Meghan De Maria is a senior editor at Eat This, Not That!, specializing in food, product, and restaurant coverage. Read more
Filed Under