Rolling in the Dough

Every Cookie in America—Ranked By Popularity

From chocolate chip to peanut butter, what cookies is your state craving?

Every Cookie in America—Ranked By Popularity

Every Cookie in America—Ranked By Popularity

From chocolate chip to peanut butter, what cookies is your state craving?

Whether you crave the sweet and salty flavors of chocolate chip, the butteriness of sugar cookies, or the warm spices in snickerdoodles, every cookie should be celebrated — and we don’t need a food holiday to reach for the cookie jar. From ice cream sandwiches to whoopie pies, cookies are arguably America’s favorite treat.

And who better to show us just how much cookies make the country go round than Nestle Toll House, who issued a nationwide consumer survey last year on the most popular cookies in the America. Kentucky loves their Bourbon Spice and Vermont prides itself in Maple Pecan. What cookie best represents the state you’re from? Find out in the list below! And if you’re wondering how to curb your sweet tooth and make your healthy cookie cravings a reality, grab a copy of The 14-Day No-Sugar Diet today!

1

Alabama

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

‘Bama is best known for their country fried steaks, banana pudding, and fried green tomatoes, but their favorite cookie is none other than peanut butter with chocolate chips. Perhaps, it’s because it’s the state where college football lives and reigns, and peanut butter makes the ultimate game-viewing snack.

2

Alaska

Russian tea cakes Shutterstock

Russian Tea Cakes

When Russia negotiated with the U.S. for the Last Frontier, they left crumbs of their culture behind in the form of Russian Tea Cakes. Russian Tea Cakes, also known as polvorones, are small balls of buttery dough filled with finely ground nuts that are rolled twice in powdered sugar. They basically look like mini snowglobes, which is exactly what the Eskimo state is.

3

Arizona

Mexican wedding cookies Shutterstock

Mexican Wedding

You’ll find the best Mexican fare around when you visit the Sunset State, so it’s not surprising that they’ve chosen Mexican Wedding cookies as their favorite treat. Mexican Wedding cookies are very similar to Russian Tea Cakes because they have a thick dusting of powdered sugar and a rich buttery texture. They’re often cut into crescent moon shapes.

4

Arkansas

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Arkansas is tucked inside the Southern belt of classic comfort food, and no cookie screams comfort quite like peanut butter with chocolate chips. Peanut butter lends a smooth and creamy texture and infuses a salty, sweet flavor that’s hard to resist. Sprinkle the dough with some chocolate chips, and you’ve got some crunch, too.

5

California

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Thanks to California’s sunny weather, it’s home to some of the tastiest foods: wine, avocados, almonds, truffle oil. Should we go on? So there’s no better way to define the Golden State than two mighty flavors: peanut butter and chocolate.

6

Colorado

Chocolate chip cookies with nuts Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip with Nuts

With its breathtaking mountain views and green plains, Colorado is all about foods that resemble their rocky roads. Whether you like chocolate chips with walnuts or pecans, you’ll need a hearty cookie to journey up the Centennial State’s stunning climbs.

7

Connecticut

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Collegiate, classic, chocolate chip: These are the best words to describe the Nutmeg State, according to its residents. But if you happen to be visiting Connecticut, be sure to dig into its quintessential suburban towns, which are also home to some of the tastiest New England eats.

8

Delaware

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate chip

During the summer, families will flock to Delaware’s oceanside towns, where farm-to-shop ice cream is a local favorite. And we bet something with chocolate chip cookies gets into a cone.

9

Florida

Orange cookies Shutterstock

Orange

The Sunshine State is all about its citrus, whether it’s key lime pie or orange juice. As the official state fruit, oranges make their way into any dessert from Miami down to the Florida Keys.

10

Georgia

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

You’d think there would be chunks of peach hiding in Georgia’s cookie, but it’s the old-fashioned PB with chocolate chips that wins the heart of Savannah.

11

Hawaii

Macadamia nut cookies Shutterstock

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut

One bite of a white chocolate macadamia nut cookie will transport you to the land of hulas and surfers. White chocolate and macadamia nuts lend a nice sweetness to the buttery cookies.

12

Idaho

Oatmeal chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

Between the potatoes, wheat, and oats, Idaho is known for its bounty of crops. Unlike refined white flour, oatmeal packs hunger-curbing fiber and other nutrients. To get an even bigger health boost, go for dark chocolate chips.

13

Illinois

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

In the land of Lincoln (and Obama), chocolate chip cookies take the cake. Its rich, buttery texture and hearty chocolate chips pay homage to the state’s diverse landscape and cultures.

14

Indiana

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

The Midwest is all about the chocolate chip cookie. Notice a trend here? The Hoosiers are no different when they for voted this classic treat.

15

Iowa

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

We think Iowa’s popular Blue Bunny ice cream will make the perfect frozen ‘wich with some chocolate chip cookies. Check out our 26 Diet Ice Creams—Ranked to get the healthiest scoop.

16

Kansas

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

With abundant farmland and cattle, you’d think that Kansas’ cookie would feature some bacon, but the “Home on the Range” is serious about sticking to their Midwestern roots with the chocolate chip cookie.

17

Kentucky

Bourbon cookies Shutterstock

Bourbon Spice

The Bluegrass State is the biggest distributor of—you guessed it—bourbon. And you bet it’s in the Commonwealth’s culinary concoctions as it is in its cocktails.

18

Louisiana

Maple pecan cookies Shutterstock

Maple Pecan

With jambalaya and gumbo, what’s not to love about Cajun and Creole country food? But when it comes to dessert, Louisiana picks maple pecan cookies over beignets.

19

Maine

Molasses cookies Shutterstock

Molasses

Lobster rolls and clam chowder aren’t the only things you’ll find to eat in this New England state. In fact, molasses seeps its way onto many of Maine’s desserts. The warm, thick and not-too-sweet taste of molasses plays well with gingerbread cookies.

20

Maryland

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Unfortunately, crab cakes aren’t offered with chocolate chip cookies in Baltimore. But we wouldn’t judge you for ordering some for dessert.

21

Massachusetts

Cranberry cookies Shutterstock

Cranberry

Massachusetts does fall flavors best, and cranberry cookies are a great celebration of the season. Adding cranberries to cookies can also help you cut back on the sugar and infuse some natural sweetness to the treat.

22

Michigan

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

The state of Michigan is the shape of an oven mitt, so it’s only fitting that they bake the best cookies, right? As one of the many states that chose this classic cookie, we could only hope that they like baking them deep-dish, Detriot-style.

23

Minnesota

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Minneapolis was formerly known as Mill City, so it’s become an epicenter for bread and baked goods in the country. The chocolate chip cookie is also the North Star’s favorite, and we’re pretty sure their pastry chefs have it down to a science.

24

Mississippi

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

As the country’s capital of Southern fare, Mississippi is all about offering up the most indulgent comfort foods. While other states on this list also voted for peanut butter and chocolate chips, we think the Magnolia State can make the treat iconic.

25

Missouri

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Yet another state on the list that loves chocolate chip cookies! If you’ve ever visited St. Louis, you know that gooey butter cake is a local favorite, and we’re pretty sure that they would make these cookies the same way.

26

Montana

Cowboy cookies Shutterstock

Cowboy

Cowboys are the bad boys in the Wild West of cookies. They’re thick and hefty with oatmeal, chocolate chips, pecans, coconut, and brown sugar.

27

Nebraska

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Omaha God! While Nebraska is filled with corn and beef, traditional chocolate chip cookies get the vote for the state’s favorite.

28

Nevada

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

If Nevadans had to choose two foods to eat in the desert, it’s peanut butter and chocolate chips. Creamy and satisfying, peanut butter seems to be everyone’s sweet savior.

29

New Hampshire

Pumpkin spice cookies Shutterstock

Pumpkin Spice

Pumpkin pie cookies come to mind when you describe New Hampshire’s foliage in food terms. Are the cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice hitting your senses yet?

30

New Jersey

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

People who hail from the Garden State will argue they’ve got the best pizza, disco fries, and Taylor ham (or is it pork roll?), so don’t expect them to think anything less of their chocolate chip cookies.

31

New Mexico

Biscochito Shutterstock

Biscochito

This cookie is a throwback to when New Mexico was still a Spanish colony. Bischochito is a butter-based cookie that’s flavored with cinnamon and anise. You can usually find the cookie in the shape of stars and crescent moons.

32

New York

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Whether you like Levain, Insomnia Cookies, or Jacques Torres, these all-star New York City bakeries house some of the best chocolate chip cookies around the block.

33

North Carolina

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

In the homeland of Krispy Kreme donuts, the Tar Heels and Blue Devils rank chocolate chip cookies number one.

34

North Dakota

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Have we convinced you yet that chocolate chip is the most popular cookies? It’s no surprise that North Dakota, which is known for its Chippers (chocolate-coated potato chips), loves the sweet and salty flavor combo in their cookies, too.

35

Ohio

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Buckeye candy happens to be a thing, and guess what it features: peanut butter and chocolate.  A ball of peanut butter fudge is coated with milk chocolate and finished with a peanut butter cap.

36

Oklahoma

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

The official state meal of Oklahoma is a heavy dish consisting of fried okra, cornbread, barbecue pork, squash, biscuits, and sausage and gravy. But for dessert, they’d rather have chocolate chip cookies instead of strawberries (their state fruit) or fried pies (a local favorite).

37

Oregon

Pumpkin spice cookies Shutterstock

Pumpkin Spice

If you’re hopping on the Oregon Trail this fall, there are plenty of pumpkin patches throughout the state to visit. The Beaver State takes pride in preparing high-quality, local food from many of its farms.

38

Pennsylvania

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

There’s more to Pennsylvania than hoagies, cheesesteaks, and shoofly pies. It’s also home to Hershey, the official distributor of Reese’s peanut butter and chocolate cups.

39

Rhode Island

Biscotti Shutterstock

Biscotti

Biscotti is most similar to Rhode Island’s hermit cookies, which is made with reused dough, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, raisins or currants, and molasses.

40

South Carolina

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Peanuts are one of South Carolina’s most abundant crops in the summer, so much that they’ve become a pantry staple in the South. Boiled peanuts, in particular, are a local favorite.

41

South Dakota

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

South Dakota State University claims it created cookies-and-cream ice cream, so we can’t help but wonder, why isn’t the Oreo their favorite cookie?

42

Tennessee

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Next to chocolate chip cookies, MoonPies are Tennessee’s next best cookie. They’re marshmallow-stuffed graham cracker sandwich with chocolate, vanilla, or banana frosted on top.

43

Texas

Cowboy cookies Shutterstock

Cowboy

There’s no better cookie to represent the Lone Star State. Cowboys are hearty cookies made with oatmeal, chocolate, chips, pecans, coconut, and brown sugar.

44

Utah

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

In Utah, there’s something called high-altitude cookies, which are essentially chocolate chip cookies. They’re very dense and are made with salted butter, brown and white sugar, vanilla, and chocolate chips.

45

Vermont

Maple pecan cookies Shutterstock

Maple Pecan

There are no two ingredients that can perfectly describe Vermont like maple syrup and pecans. The Green Mountain State is dotted with maple trees and local shops that make Grade A and B syrups.

46

Virginia

Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Peanut Butter with Chocolate Chips

Virginia is famous for their peanut pie, where peanuts are roasted and combined with a gooey golden syrup mixture. If you can’t find a slice of this heavenly pie, a peanut butter cookie with chocolate chips will have to do.

47

Washington

Apple cinnamon cookies Shutterstock

Apple Cinnamon

The Evergreen State loves their apple cider donuts, so it’s only natural that it’s their favorite cookie flavor, too.

48

West Virginia

Haystacks cookies Courtesy of m01229/Flickr

Haystacks

Haystacks cookies are usually a mound of peanut butter, butterscotch, chocolate, marshmallows and chow mein noodles or oats. The best part is they don’t require any baking—you can use your microwave to melt the ingredients together and allow them to set in the fridge.

49

Wisconsin

Chocolate chip cookies Shutterstock

Chocolate Chip

Wisconsin is the land of beer and Colby cheese, but their sweet tooth loves the most popular cookies: chocolate chip.

50

Wyoming

Cowboy cookies Shutterstock

Cowboy

You’ll need Cowboy cookies to fuel your hikes and adventures through Wyoming’s mountain ranges, rich farmland, and stunning national parks. To fuel even more adventures, don’t miss these 25 Best & Worst Low-Sugar Protein Bars.

No-Diet Weight Loss—Guaranteed!

Look, feel and live great while getting on the path to better health with the new Eat This, Not That! Magazine